Wolves, Dogs and Training

Wolves, Dogs, and Training: Why the Wolf Model Was Wrong

For many years, dog training was based on the idea that domestic dogs behave like wolves. Trainers and researchers believed that since dogs descended from wolves, they must operate under similar dominance-based social structures. This led to training methods that focused on pack leadership, dominance, and submission. However, modern research has disproven many of these early assumptions, reshaping how we train and understand our canine companions.

The Origins of the Wolf Model in Dog Training

The idea that dogs behave like wolves originated from wolf studies conducted in the 1930s and 1940s. One of the most influential studies was by Swiss animal behaviourist Rudolf Schenkel in 1947, who observed wolves in captivity and concluded that they formed strict hierarchical packs with an "alpha" at the top enforcing dominance over subordinates.

This research became widely accepted in dog training, especially with the release of L. David Mech’s book "The Wolf: Ecology and Behavior of an Endangered Species" in 1970, which described pack hierarchies and dominant "alpha" wolves. Trainers adopted these concepts, believing that owners needed to establish dominance over their dogs through forceful techniques such as alpha rolls and punishment-based corrections.

Why the Wolf Model Was Wrong

Flawed Wolf Research
- The original wolf studies were conducted on wolves in captivity, not wild wolves. Captive wolves were forced into unnatural groups, leading to high stress and aggressive dominance behaviour that does not occur in the wild.
- In the 1990s and early 2000s, researchers like L. David Mech himself revisited wild wolf behaviour and discovered that wolf packs function more like family units, with parents leading their offspring rather than enforcing dominance through aggression.
Dogs Are Not Wolves
- Dogs diverged from wolves at least 15,000–40,000 years ago. Through domestication, dogs evolved to be more cooperative with humans, relying on human guidance rather than rigid dominance structures.
- Unlike wolves, domestic dogs do not naturally form strict hierarchical packs. Instead, they develop social relationships based on learning, trust, and positive interactions.
The Rise of Science-Based Training
- By the early 2000s, canine behaviourists and trainers started advocating for positive reinforcement methods, focusing on reward-based training rather than dominance-based correction.
- Studies showed that forceful training methods often lead to fear, stress, and behavioural issues, whereas reward-based training builds confidence, trust, and reliability in dogs.

Modern Dog Training: Moving Beyond the Wolf Model

With dominance theories debunked, modern dog training prioritises:

Positive Reinforcement: Rewarding desired behaviours to encourage repetition (e.g., using treats, praise, or playtime).
Clear Communication: Using markers like “Yes!” or clickers to reinforce correct actions immediately.
Building Trust: Strengthening the human-dog bond through mutual understanding rather than forced submission.
Understanding Canine Psychology: Recognising that dogs are individuals with different learning styles, emotions, and needs.

Final Thoughts

While wolves and dogs share ancestry, modern science has proven that training dogs as if they were wolves is ineffective and potentially harmful. Thanks to updated research from the 1990s onwards, we now understand that dogs learn best through clear communication, trust, and positive reinforcement. By letting go of outdated dominance myths, we can train our dogs in a way that fosters mutual respect and cooperation, leading to happier, well-adjusted companions.

📍 Areas Covered: Halifax, Brighouse, Elland, Queensbury, Low Moor, Wyke, Shelf, Claremount, Boothtown, Sowerby Bridge, Southowram, Northowram, Hipperholme, West Vale, Wheatley, Pellon, Copley, Coley, Norwood Green, Wibsey and surrounding areas. If your area is not on here, just contact us to check. We cover much further for training.